One-star Ratings on Amazon for Book Without Kindle Version

In What's the Buzz by Hannah Johnson

By Hannah Johnson

Game Change by Heilemann and Halperin

The recently released book, Game Change by John Heilemann and Mark Halperin (published by Harper), was well-received by newspaper and online book reviewers for its examination of the 2008 presidential campaign in the USA and how Obama won the election.

So why does this book have a 2/5 star-rating on

It has nothing to do with the content. Kindle users are upset over the delayed e-book release of Game Change and they have collectively given the book one-star ratings in protest.

However, this has also sparked a debate in the book’s discussion forum about the fairness of this tactic and whether ratings should pertain only to the book’s content or also to its format. Readers without Kindles are upset by the ratings manipulation, and some are calling for Amazon to delete the one-star ratings for this book.

As more consumers start reading e-books, I think we can expect this type of debate to intensify. The good news is that readers are still passionate about their books, no matter which side of the debate they are on.

About the Author

Hannah Johnson


Hannah Johnson is the Publisher of Publishing Perspectives. Before joining PP in 2009, she worked as Project Manager at the German Book Office New York.