
Jill Lepore (credit: Johannes Minkus).
By Andrew Richard Albanese, Editor-in-Chief
“The love of books is still flourishing and is pulsating,” said Sebastian Guggolz, Chairman of the German Publishers and Booksellers Association, in his remarks at the October 6 opening press conference for the 78th Frankfurter Buchmesse. That’s the good news. But the world of books and reading is also facing a host of epic challenges as the industry comes together for this year’s buchmesse—including the issue on everyone’s minds: the advent of AI.
(From left): FBM Press Officer Torsten Casimir; Sebastian Guggolz, Chairman of the German Publishers and Booksellers Association;, Juergen Boos, Director of Frankfurter Buchmesse; and American historian and author Jill Lepore (credit: Johannes Minkus).
“The problem of reading competence cannot be compensated by AI, which delivers answers at random,” Guggolz said. “This should alarm us not just us as a book industry, but also the whole of society.” In his remarks, Guggolz urged “immediate intervention” from world leaders, without authors and publishers “having to sue first”—an appeal that will surely be a major message coming from this year’s fair.
Against this backdrop, American historian and Pulitzer Prize-winning author Jill Lepore delivered a powerful keynote, warning against a world in which our future is handed over to a cadre of tech moguls.
“This fair rests on a tradition more than five hundred years old, older, even, than the printing trade. Yet we meet here this year on the knife-edge of history,” Lepore told the assembled press. “The sum of human knowledge that is contained in the world’s books has been swallowed whole by machines owned by corporations. These corporations propose that these intelligent machines do the work of reading and writing and even of thinking for us. For all the wonders and marvels of these machines, for all the promise they hold for the discovery of new knowledge, their development threatens the arts and letters, freedom of thought, democratic societies, and if the warnings issued by the tech moguls themselves are to be believed, even humanity itself.”
In a bracing, 15-minute address, Lepore whose latest book, The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State, warns against an insidious, anti-democratic tech takeover, spoke of a future commanded by “a very small number of staggeringly powerful 21st century merchant princes,” obsessed with a future ripped from the pages of science fiction.
“The Artificial State they envision for everyone else, and have begun to build, is a future in which humans are ruled, and many replaced, by machines owned by corporations,” she said. “What do humans sacrifice in surrendering to the Artificial State? I believe it’s worth wondering whether we risk losing not only our freedom but also our minds.”
A scholar of the American Constitution, whose 2025 book We the People: A History of the U.S. Constitution won the Pulitzer Prize for History, Lepore leaned on history in warning that the pillars of U.S. democracy are weakened in a future where the “consent of the governed” rests upon a handful of corporations who control the information landscape. Constitutional democracy “depends on books, and reading, on writers and printers, on the freedom of the human mind,” she said. “No democracy can thrive without a literate electorate. It is an inheritance as precious as it is precarious.”
Of course, Lepore noted, democracy is hardly perfect. “One need only look at the history of my own country to list the imperfections of this form of government, its many errors, its vulnerabilities,” she said. But, she insisted, the forms of rule that preceded the advent of constitutional democracy—and those that “are beginning to replace them”—are far worse.
“Nearly two and a half centuries ago, Americans decided that societies of people are indeed capable of governing themselves by reflection and choice rather than being ruled by accident and force,” she concluded. “But now the question has returned, slightly revised: Are humans to abandon government by consent for government by machine? Are we to allow machines to do our reading and writing and thinking for us? Or are we, as we do here this week, to declare our independence, in the writing and reading of books? Because I hold this truth to be self-evident: that our thoughts and our words—and our books—are our own, and that consent to any system of government is ours to give, or to withhold.”
‘The Frankfurt Declaration’
Lepore’s words come as the Börsenverein des Deutschen Buchhandels (the German Publishers and Booksellers Association) has issued the “Frankfurt appeal,” a petition legislators urging action to regulate AI.
“Issued on the occasion of the Frankfurt Book Fair, this appeal calls on you, as legislators, to provide a clear statutory response to a structural problem affecting every single publishing house: AI companies train their models on copyright-protected works without the consent of publishers and authors, exploit valuable products without remuneration, and to date have largely acted with impunity, even when unlawfully disregarding express rights reservations by rightsholders,” the appeal states. “As legislators, you bear responsibility for putting in place a legal framework governing the development and use of AI which provides for clear obligations and liability rules.”
Specifically, publishers signing on to the declaration (dozens so far), are calling for: Transparency obligations for AI companies that must include the disclosure of the specific training data used at work level; the establishment of a licensing market with fair revenue models; and that European copyright law must be “complied with and equipped with robust means of enforcement.:
The full declaration can be viewed (and signed) here.
The 78th Frankfurther Buchmesse officially kicks off tomorrow, running from October 7-11
More of Publishing Perspectives‘ Frankfurt Book Fair Preview:
- Frankfurter Buchmesse 2026: Program Picks
- Frankfurter Buchmesse 2026: ‘On the Books’ – What Everyone in Publishing Will Be Talking About
- Frankfurter Buchmesse 2026: What’s Next for Juergen Boos?
- Frankfurter Buchmesse 2026: A conversation with Czech author and European Prize for Literature winner Dora Kaprálová

