By Porter Anderson, Editor-in-Chief | @Porter_Anderson
Lotinga: ‘Absolutely No Room for Complacency’The United Kingdom’s Publishers Association—arguably the world leader in its focus on diversity, inclusion, and equity—has issued an update to its survey work, shortly before the first edition of London Book Fair to be held in person since 2019.
Published a week ago today (April 1), the new “Diversity Survey of the [UK] Publishing Workforce” for 2021 from the association had the participation of 14,089 employees from 60 businesses. Several top-line observations are offered by the association CEO Stephen Lotinga and his staff.
And particularly as international trade visitors arrive in the UK for London Book Fair—just as the BBC reports that a record 4.9 million people have the coronavirus COVID-19 in the UK, no less—the findings of the association’s new survey should be interesting to everyone who has watched this market come together in an effort to change its stance on these crucial issues.
Who is working in world publishing and its national markets today? How readily do those people reflect the populations of the markets they serve?
First, those key findings, as interpreted by the Publishers Association:
- More than half of those in the UK publishing industry’s executive leadership and senior management positions are female
- UK publishing executives are 52-percent female in the results gathered by this survey
- Women hold 56 percent of the UK publishing senior management roles in the survey’s results
- Overall, 63 percent of survey respondents were women
- The presence of people from ethnic minority groups–excluding white minorities–has increased to 15 percent, a number that achieves the Publishers Association’s target in this category for 2022
- LGB+ representation continues to increase, with 13 percent of respondents either identifying themselves as lesbian, gay, or bisexual, or preferring to describe their sexual orientation, a figure which has grown each year since 2017
- One percent of respondents identify themselves in survey responses as transgender, which is in line with the UK population according to estimates of the British Government Equalities Office
- The representation in the UK’s publishing industry of people with disabilities has increased over the years from 2 percent in 2017 to 13 percent in 2021
- Socio-economic background continues to represent major barriers to inclusion, with around two thirds, 67 percent, of respondents being from professional backgrounds
- Those who were privately educated, at 19 percent, and those “educated to a degree level,’ at 83 percent, continue, as the association’s interpretation recognizes “to be overrepresented in the workforce by comparison to the population
In a comment made on the release of the new survey data, Lotinga is quoted, saying, “It’s heartening to see that progress is being made in several areas. There are definitely some things to welcome and, crucially, some potential signs that the work that publishers have been doing to improve diversity, inclusion and belonging for staff is beginning to help move the dial.
“However, there is absolutely no room for complacency. In many areas, the pace of change is not enough. Socio-economic background continues to represent a major barrier to inclusion in our industry, as it does in many others. A lack of regional diversity remains stark.
“There is still much to be done and the Publishers Association [is] working with publishers and partners to plan the next phase of our inclusivity work and will share information about this later in the year.”
In considering these factors, it’s helpful to look at data on the wider population. Unfortunately, the latest census data for the UK is from 2011. The association notes that a new census was made in 2021 and that it expects to thus have an update on these factors later this year.
From that 2011 census, however, in England and Wales:
- 86.0 percent were from white ethnic groups
- 7.5 percent were from Asian ethnic groups
- 3.3 percent were from Black ethnic groups
- 2.2 percent said they were of mixed ethnicities
- One percent belonged to other ethnic groups
In Lotinga’s introductory comments for the report itself, he notes that the association’s “action plan” is reaching the end of its original term of survey activity. “We’re working with our members and industry partners to adjust our strategy to reflect evolving conversations, publisher activity, and best practice in this area,” he writes.
In further key findings of the survey, 93 percent of the respondents to the survey (over 87 percent in 2020) identified their national identity as at least one of the following:
- Northern Irish
One in six identified their national identity as being other than British or one of the “home nations.”
Working From Home, and Women’s Leadership
Among the most interesting COVID-19 era data from the survey is the fact that in the 2020 survey, 89 percent of respondents said they had the ability to work from home after the first lockdown, while before that, only 40 percent could work from home. In 2021, the Johnson government first lifted most spread-mitigation efforts in July, and then asked citizens to work from home where practical in December, creating a somewhat less clear picture, but with “almost two-fifths of respondents (38 percent) working from home around five days per week.
In gender issues, the World Bank sees 47 percent of the British workforce to be female, while 63 percent in UK publishing are women.
One of the most impressive elements of the UK’s analysis of its publishing industry is a finding that runs counter to the situation in many other markets: women continue to hold more than 50 percent of executive leadership positions in the UK and senior management roles, satisfying the Publishers Association’s goal of at least 50 percent.
More detail can be had in a download (PDF) of the 30-page report here.
And what’s important for trade visitors to London Book Fair to keep in mind is that the United Kingdom industry may not have all the answers or the progress it wants in issues of diversity, equity, or inclusivity, but it probably has taken a more forthright, persistent, and structured approach–including repeated survey and evaluation–than other book business markets of the world.
It’s an example worth examining and a lead worth following.
For your review, here’s our report from last year’s survey work in which women’s progress in leadership positions was becoming firmly evident.
More from us on the coronavirus COVID-19 pandemic and its impact on international book publishing is here.