« Digital

Hybrid Author Hugh Howey on Self vs. Traditional Publishing

indie author hugh howey

“Indie authors are maniacally focused on the reader.” Hugh Howey unboxes the first shipment from CreateSpace of his newest novel “Dust” on camera for his readers. The self-publishing phenom thanks Jason Smith of his traditional publisher Random House UK for designing the trilogy’s radiant covers and thanks Random House for letting them be used throughout the English-language territories.

By Porter Anderson

If publishers price their ebooks low enough…readers will buy more than one version of the same book.

Speaking earlier this month, a few days before Amazon announced its MatchBook plan to offer “bundling” of low-cost or free ebooks with print book purchases, self-publishing entrepreneur and hybrid author Hugh Howey was — as seems usual — a bit ahead of the game: “Ebook-plus-audio or ebook-plus-print,” he told Publishing Perspectives in an interview. “Ebooks should be seen as both an add-on and an entrance to other products. They should not be seen as competition to print and other formats. Giving away an ebook with every sale of a hardback would do wonders for the hardback market.”

What’s more, Howey had what might be a controversial but potentially ingenious suggestion: an imprint created expressly to market ebook bestsellers in print.

“The first major publisher who creates an imprint dedicated to this model will do very well for their bottom line,” he said. “It just requires thinking outside the box, not worrying about upsetting other publishers (who should be their competitors), and seeing the publishing relationship more as a partnership and less as an acquisition.”

Howey will be a featured speaker at this year’s CONTEC Frankfurt Conference on October 8, joining the Interactive Learning Lab session, “Self-Publishing and Its Implications for the Industry.” He’ll be joined by his literary agent Kristin Nelson of Nelson Literary.

Howey is one of the most closely followed of today’s elite club of international entrepreneurial authors whose self-publishing success brings them enviable sales in the millions, both in dollars and units. Among writers and a lot of readers, this is a rock star.

His latest release, Dust, the third book in his Silo Saga trilogy, debuted at No. 7 on the New York Times Best Seller List (combined print and ebook listings) and sold some 50,000 copies in its  first week on sale.

With Nelson’s representation, Howey inked a print-only contract with Simon & Schuster in the US for Wool — released in stores on March 12 of this year — and with Random House in the UK for the trilogy. Hollywood A-list director Ridley Scott optioned the film rights to Wool with Oscar-winner Steve Zallian slated to write the script.

Wool by hugh howey

A shot of Wool on sale in a bookstore window in Australia.

How To Be “Maniacally Focused on the Reader”

Howey is part of a generation of writers who have leveraged new media to develop direct personal relationships with readers.

For example, in a recent video blog he showed off the amber Dust hardcover as it arrived from Random House UK. The moment was typical of how faithfully he shares such high points with “you guys,” his loyal ragazzi. This time, he explained his fondness for paper-over-board printing. If his fans agreed that the format is preferable to loose dust jackets, he said, “You might want to let publishers know…you want more books made like that. Well, I don’t know if they’d listen to you. But make your voice heard.”

In It’s the Reader, Stupid, a synopsis of a longer essay, Howey pressed home one of his key messages for today’s writers:

Indie authors are maniacally focused on the reader, almost to the exclusion of anything else. Low prices, fun and interesting genres and styles, a direct relationship, frequent output, you name it. Indie authors are doing well because they know it’s all about the reader.

Howey’s guileless enjoyment of every aspect of his career and his willingness to travel and engage with his fans on his own dime — flying or driving from meetup to release party to book fair to This Con and That Con — keeps him “up to date on the status of the industry and energized to keep writing and working hard,” he said.

To get a sense of just how committed he is, take a look at a recent slice of his promotional activity:

  • While at the Tampa Comic Con, he jumps onto HughHowey.com to share an anecdote about a reader, “Sarah,” discovering his table inside the cavernous Tampa Bay Convention Center: She “teared up and freaked out when she saw that I was there. Wool is her all-time favorite novel, she says. Today, she is my all-time favorite fan.”
  • He leaves Tampa, flies to California, rents a car and drives for an hour out of San Francisco to surprise readers at a Dust release party at a shopping-center restaurant, later streaming it on video to fans on his site. He wryly notes that he had to wait for his cue to go into the restaurant, lurking in a playground with his video camera — dodging mistrustful parental glances.
  • Then he’s off to San Antonio for the 71st World Con, responding to his experience of meeting authors there with serious, instructive writings such as the short, pointed essay about staying grounded, The Work is the Work. The Path is the Path.

Looking ahead to his first visit to the Frankfurt Book Fair, we wanted to know what advice Howey might offer to publishers based on his own experience.

He went straight for pricing: “Related to competition between formats, backlist ebooks should not be seen as competition to frontlist ebooks,” Howey said. “There seems to be some hesitation to lower the price of older titles. Publishers can drastically cut the price on these books without cannibalizing new releases. This is partly because of our willingness to collect books we’ve already loved and enjoyed in other formats.

“That brings me one of the strangest phenomenons with low-priced ebooks: readers will buy ebooks that they never go on to read, and they won’t feel a single ounce of regret about this. Physical books clutter our homes and sit as reminders of all that we aren’t reading. There’s a psychological cost to buying a print book that includes where we will store the book, the fact that we have a massive TBR [to be read] pile leaning against the wall by our beds, and that we’ll have to box up and move these books. Also, when we don’t finish a book, there is a psychological cost to the money spent. This disinclines us to buying more books.

“Ebooks change all of these calculations. If they are inexpensive enough, they will sit on devices the way underused apps sit on smartphones: paid for, never opened, and not competing with the next sale. There’s no buyer’s remorse. No physical clutter. This is a topic, these psychological forces, that goes unexplored, but is crucial to pricing strategies.”

Seeking More Transparency

Wool OmnibuIf Howey were in a room with his top 30 global self-publishing author-peers, what would he hear them talk about the most?

He mentioned “more transparency in publishing deals, a new backend that gives near real-time sales data and pays monthly rather than biannually. The technology is there.

“Inventory and sales management,” he said. “You can’t press a button and tell how many books you’ve sold in a month or over your lifetime. My agent wants this information, and it requires going to Amazon, Nook, Kobo, iBookstore, ACX for audiobook sales, CreateSpace for physical sales, my website for direct sales, and then checking with publishers.”

Audiobooks and Foreign Rights

“Another thing I’d hear from the top 30 authors is their amazement at secondary markets and their frustrations with English-language markets. Every top-selling indie author I know is doing very well with audiobooks. Better than major publishers do with comparable print and ebook sales, in fact. I had a six-figure offer for the audio rights to the Silo Saga. I’ve made more than that on my own in less than a year, and those earnings will continue for many years to come.

“Another secondary market that these top 30 authors would rave about,” Howey said, “is a market I value as highly as my home market — foreign publishers. I think the top authors would all remark on how powerful translation rights are and how fair the contracts are. The limited terms of license are something we’d love to see in the US and the UK.

“We want less money up-front and a better split down the road, or a road that has a finite end in sight where we can renegotiate. I think publishers would do well to move away from massive advances and embrace more of a partnership with authors, especially the entrepreneurial ones who are already earning a great living and don’t want to give up their monthly wage in exchange for a one-time windfall.”

More Speed to Market Is Needed

Shift by @HughHowey Random House coverHowey has an interesting take on the speed needed to get a runaway-hit ebook into the print distribution it needs.

“There should be a better way to get a hot ebook into the hands of print book readers. Fifty Shades of Grey was a model for this, with books turned around swiftly with not a lot of manipulation in order to capitalize on demand. Successful ebooks shouldn’t be treated like manuscripts, in my opinion. There’s an existing readership to tap into, and time is of the essence.”

At one point in the interview, Howey made it clear that he doesn’t look on traditional publishing with hostility, as is sometimes assumed about self-publishing authors.

“I think most self-published authors understand and appreciate the power and capabilities of major publishing houses,” he said. “They know the cover art is generally better, that there’ll be help with blurbs and endorsements, and that print distribution will be stronger. But I also think they understand the limitations of major publishers better than even publishers are aware of them, and this cost analysis makes many of us wary about giving up our rights.”

Publishers Don’t Necessarily Need Self-Published Bestsellers

Howey has no delusions about the plethora of available content these days.

“Publishers are in a situation where the supply of manuscripts is so great that they can ignore self-publishing bestsellers and still have their pipelines full of content,” he said.

“But publishers are also risk-averse, and a bestseller is a bestseller. They just need to learn which books make this transition the best. And they should embrace leaving well enough alone, while trying to add value. I know indies (I’m one of them) who are making six figures a year on their print-on-demand books who would gladly hand over the rights to these books to publishers for them to get them out to bookstores.

“We would take the hit on earnings just to cultivate a relationship with publishers, booksellers, and print readers. That’s guaranteed and easy money for publishers, but without the upside of digital sales.”

Publishers are Backing Off of Print-Only Deals

Dust by @HughHoweyWhen it comes to his proposal of developing an imprint specifically to port bestselling ebooks into print, Howey conceded, the prospects may not be good.

“Publishers seem to be circling the wagons and backing away from print-only deals,” he said. “They have enough books to take all the rights for that I don’t think they want to set much precedent with the print-only deals. Wool did well for Simon & Schuster, despite their problems getting the book into Barnes & Noble bookstores [because of retail contract negotiations, now resolved], so there is money to be made here.

“But they know that ebooks are the way forward for profits. The only offer we’ve had has been for all rights, print and digital.”

And that being the case? It is good to be Hugh Howey.

“I’m in no hurry. I sold over 6,000 print books this month through Amazon and directly to readers. These are self-published print-on-demand books. I could live comfortably on these sales alone, so I can afford to hold off for a deal that makes sense to both sides.”

DISCUSS: 10 Counterintuitive Tips for Self-Publishers

At CONTEC on October 8, Hugh Howey and his agent Kristin Nelson will be joined in our special session on self-publishing and its implications for the industry by colleagues including Peter Armstrong of Leanpub; Amanda Barbara of Pubslush; Jon Fine of Amazon; Jonny Geller of Curtis Brown; Florian Geuppert of Books on Demand; journalist Matthias Matting; and Michael Tamblyn of Kobo. More information is at the conference’s site. A 20% discount is available on registration with the use of the code CONTEC13KPTW20. Pre-registration for the special session is encouraged.

This entry was posted in Digital and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.

14 Comments

  1. Posted September 9, 2013 at 12:09 pm | Permalink

    Great article–clear picture of indie success without hostility for trad publishing, and suggestions for going forward.

    • Posted September 9, 2013 at 5:33 pm | Permalink

      Hey, thanks, Barbara,

      Great of you to join us here today and I especially appreciate your pickup on the lack of negativity in Howey’s comments. This is one of the factors I like best in his approach — he’s a realist when it comes to where the shortcomings lie, but he takes a positive tack on the whole picture and appreciates where everyone’s strengths lie. He’s going to be an eloquent member of our discussion at CONTEC in Frankfurt, too.

      Thanks again, very good to have you with us.
      -p.
      On Twitter: @Porter_Anderson

  2. Posted September 9, 2013 at 6:26 pm | Permalink

    A good article, thanks for posting. I’m hoping that Hugh is wrong about print-only deals getting rarer. There actually are very few that I’m aware of: his, Bella Andre, Coleen Hoover, Brandon Sanderson (for his novellas, and myself. It may be that the big publishers won’t do them, but there are plenty of smaller publishers that will fill that void. Myself and Brandon Sanderson both went with Tachyon Publications that has a proven track record both in distribution and for getting industry awards such as the Hugo and the Nebula.

    I would echo a need for more transparency in contracts, faster speed to market, real time sales reporting, monthly rather than bi-annual paychecks, contracts with termination dates, and less money up front in exchange for a bigger cut of the pie.

    • Posted September 10, 2013 at 5:53 pm | Permalink

      Thanks, Michael,

      I share your concern about the question of print-only deals in the future, though I also think Howey is seeing this correctly. I see similar signs. And they indicate, of course, that your idea of looking to smaller but influential presses in print production may well be the answer. Eventually the best of print distribution will be available to all, but it’s going to take more time for that one, as the disruption continues to rebalance the relative market strengths of digital and print.

      Many thanks for being with us and for your good input in response to these fine comments from Howey. Do look up our session in Frankfurt if you’ll be at the Book Fair.

      Cheers,
      -p.
      On Twitter: @Porter_Anderson

  3. Posted September 10, 2013 at 8:42 am | Permalink

    Great article. I just self-published my debut novel on all e-readers and my print book is in process via CreateSpace. I can totally relate to everything Hugh says here and I am glad my ideas are validated by reading this article. Now I know that I am on the right track with my thinking and approach. Great value added for the few minutes spent reading this.

    • Porter Anderson
      Posted September 10, 2013 at 5:57 pm | Permalink

      Thanks very much, Karynne,

      I’m glad that you find Howey’s comments are meshing with your experiences, great of you to offer us this input. All the best with your newly published work, and thanks again for taking the time to comment.

      -p.
      On Twitter: @Porter_Anderson

  4. pat goodheart
    Posted September 10, 2013 at 1:13 pm | Permalink

    I was much taken with your remarks concerning the publication of your novel on Create Space. As a publisher, translator, novelist whose principal work emerged in the era prior to the use of the computor, I felt the need to bring my list up to date in the 21st century. We begin our program with the publication of THE WORDS TO SAY IT by Marie Cardinal with preface and afterward by Bruno Bettelheim, translated by Pat Goodheart. It is the story of a recovery from madness, which reads like a thriller and has become a classic in our edition, taught in over 750 colleges and universities, including Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Berkely, Stanford, etc. For it is time to introduce this autobiographical novel to a new generation of readers. At the same time, I will be bringing out THE TRANSLATOR, by Pat Goodheart, a novel which will serve as my calling card in the promotion and marketing of our emerging list. For we will be bringing out new work as well. It is the promotion and marketing of the books that will occupy me and my partner Nicholas Van Vactor. How to achieve the best possible results in today’s market, using social media as well as standard venues. I am tempted to move forward with the book on tapes aspect which you write about, the more so after reading your piece.
    Many thanks for your most informative piece.

    With all good wishes,

    Pat Goodheart
    Publisher
    Van Vactor & Goodheart
    955 MASS AV
    Cambridge, MA 02139

    • Porter Anderson
      Posted September 10, 2013 at 6:03 pm | Permalink

      Hello, Pat,

      Realizing your comment is directed to Hugh Howey, I don’t mean to intercede here, but just want to thank you for reading the fine interview he gave us and for sharing this experience of updating your list. Based on comments Howey has made at many points when I was in earshot, I’d urge you to explore the audiobook option. The ACX program now makes it far easier than in the past to create and sell audio editions of books (with professional narration). Let me offer you this link to the ACX information page (this, like CreateSpace, is an Amazon initiative in association with Audible.com, which Amazon owns). Many of the most elite of our entrepreneurial authors, like Howey, are telling me how good the response is to their audiobooks efforts. I hope it might be worth your consideration.

      Thank you again for reading and commenting, good to have you with us at Publishing Perspectives.
      -p.
      On Twitter: @Porter_Anderson

  5. Posted September 11, 2013 at 10:30 am | Permalink

    Fascinating article! Although I’m a bit chuffed to see (although I totally believe it) that traditional publishers are growing cold on print-only deals.

    I’m one of those feckless bloggers who recently turned down a publishing offer to go independent. Time will tell if this was a wise move or not. But all of the points Hugh makes are essentially the reasons I made this choice: time to market, lack of visibility, no shared benefit down the long road. It wasn’t about being greedy or resentful about traditional publishers, it was a matter of weighing pros and cons.

    But admittedly I have harbored secret hopes of garnering a print-only deal after establishing (hopefully) some validating sales numbers. How sad to see that it’s unlikely to come to pass.

    • Porter Anderson
      Posted September 14, 2013 at 11:21 am | Permalink

      Hi, Alexis, great of you to read and comment, thank you.

      Just a note from my Australian friend Faye (pronounced “Fie,” of course) — “chuffed” means glad, not disappointed. So if I read you correctly, you’re likely not chuffed to read Howey saying that print-only deals for major entrepreneurial sellers may be on the quick decline.

      I’m sorry to hear this, too, because I think a model in which the print-distribution power of major houses is combined with the leading edge of ebook best-selling work (as we’ve seen demonstrated in Howey’s case and some others) is a good one. It doesn’t, apparently, however, carry enough of what such publishers feel they need from such arrangements and Howey may be right that these instances will be fewer and farther between.

      I like this idea of an imprint formed to perform just this function for major best-selling self-published ebooks (staffed and run by people who, as Howey notes, know how to tell which books should have this treatment and which shouldn’t ). I’d love to know whether there’s a way the numbers can add up for a major house to mount such an imprint and give it a go.

      Thanks again,
      -p.
      On Twitter: @Porter_Anderson

  6. Posted September 14, 2013 at 11:29 am | Permalink

    Just reading the interview with Hugh Howey makes me want to buy the Silo Saga trilogy in print and ebook formats! Impressive and encouraging for Indie publishers world wide!

    Pat Alvarado
    Children’s Book Publisher & Author
    Piggy Press Books
    Republic of Panama

    • Porter Anderson
      Posted September 18, 2013 at 6:41 am | Permalink

      Thank you, Pat,

      Great to hear from you, and all the best in your work.

      -p.
      On Twitter: @Porter_Anderson

  7. Posted September 18, 2013 at 4:56 pm | Permalink

    I hope I don’t sound completely backwards, but HOW do you sell a print-on-demand book via Amazon? WHO is doing the demanded printing?

    Over the past decade I’ve tried several different publishing methods with several different books of mine, and none have been particularly successful. Then again, I’m a little lax in the PR department. Success stories like yours mystify me.

    • Porter Anderson
      Posted September 21, 2013 at 11:33 am | Permalink

      Marcy,

      No, you don’t sound backward, but indeed, a litle research would be smart. I can make this easier for you with this link. That will take you to the information page at Amazon’s CreateSpace, which is what you’re asking about. CreateSpace is the wing of Amazon’s self-publishing services that allows you to create print books. All the best in your work and thanks for joining us here on the Ether at Publishing Perspectives!
      -p.
      On Twitter: @Porter_Anderson

  • SIGN UP NOW!
    Enter your email address below to receive daily news updates from Publishing Perspectives.
    Click here to learn more about our newsletters
  • Monetize Your Backlist

    Organized by Publishing Perspectives

    Hear experts from publishing and technology discuss strategies and tools you can use to generate more revenue from your backlist content.

    What: Monetizing the Backlist event
    When: 9am–1pm on April 24, 2014
    Where: Scholastic Headquarters, NYC

    Buy your tickets now!