« Discussion

Are Reports of the Death of the Book App Premature?

By Edward Nawotka

Today’s feature story looks at the launch of NBC Publishing, a new big media venture into publishing. The business plan is predicated on producing enhanced e-books and leveraging the production know how of the television network. Nearly one year ago at the digital conference preceding the London Book Fair, Bloomsbury’s Evan Schnittman pronounced the enhanced e-book and e-book apps “dead.” (It is he who provided them with a lovely tombstone.)

At the time I remember thinking this was somewhat self-serving — after all, Schnittman works for a company that has a long, prestigious, profitable history in print, so why wouldn’t he say that?! But just last week, timed with the NBC announcement, Forrester Research’s James McQuivey released findings from a survey that stated 15% of publishers think apps are a significant revenue opportunity (down from 34% a year ago). Nevertheless, 75% of publishers still produce apps, though the number being released each year is falling — and half think they cost too much to produce.

The findings appear to reinforce Schnittman’s assessment. But the fact is, publishers were always going to find that apps “cost too much to produce” — after all, they are publishing companies, not production companies. When you look at the companies producing the most successful enhanced e-books and apps, they are very often start-ups that were able to bring together diverse sets of skills and know-how (often from television and film) to establish production work-flows that can efficiently, and one would presume, cost-effectively produce apps and enhanced e-books.

Open Road Media is just one example; Moonbot Studios — the producer of The Fantastic Flying Book of Mr. Morris Lessmore — is another. These are companies that are just getting started and slowly building an audience. That NBC Universal has jumped into the game makes sense. As the new launch’s GM Michael Fabiano pointed out, “The cost structure for us to get into this is different than for a publisher…it’s all sunk costs.”

Sam Missingham has a wonderful assessment of the situation over on FutureBook, in which she underscores what may be the major issue:

“You only have to take a quick look at the products currently on the market to see that publishers have no problem producing gorgeous, amazing apps when they set their minds to it…but then have very little idea of what to do next, specifically how to market them.”

Let us know what you think in the comments.

This entry was posted in Discussion and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.


  1. Posted January 31, 2012 at 5:09 am | Permalink

    I highly recommend Sam Missingham’s Futurebook post mentioned above. It’s a great summary of the publishing industry’s current attitude towards app development.

    I feel strongly enough about the subject that I’ve repeated my Futurebook comment below. The sentiment is the same now that NBC, Moonbot Studios and many others are gaining ground in areas that publishers should have claimed years, not months ago.

    Over the next 12 months we’re working with a collection of the greatest musicians of the last 4 decades, iconic film properties, automotive legends, global hallowed institutions and some of the most compelling authors of our time.

    This is all irresistible subject matter with essential written narrative but not a single book amongst them – they’re apps.

    This is bigger than publishing. Get over it.

    Apps aren’t something new that only publishing is dabbling with. Encapsulated mobile content has the power to touch all our lives and encourage all generations to engage with words and images.

    This is fun, fulfilling and the future so choose the right content, make the best product you can and tell the world about it. Two out of three just isn’t good enough.

  2. Posted January 31, 2012 at 1:42 pm | Permalink

    I like book apps too and the idea of enhanced ebooks. Things that pull everything together: video, music, words (perhaps perfumes some day??)

    There’s little doubt that NBC has a head start with its “sunk costs”: its archives on the one hand, and a ready market of fans. Great prospect! But why can’t publishers jump in on the bandwagon? I think they should. They could work out cooperative agreements. If NBC wants “big authors”, well, guess where they are!

  3. Posted February 1, 2012 at 4:13 am | Permalink

    Anyone who has seen the Malcolm Tucker app knows that there are no shortage of great ideas at companies like Faber but it’s telling that the app was actually developed by Agant. Perhaps we’ll see more of these kind of collaborations in the future?

  • Get Publishing Perspectives in your inbox each day and stay up-to-date on international publishing.