« Discussion

Books vs. Internet: Whose Information Is More Accurate?

By Hannah Johnson

library computers

Roger Tagholm reports on a makeshift library called Star Books (named for a nearby Starbucks) that has been set up at the Occupy London protest site near St. Paul’s Cathedral. Speaking about why he set up the library at the protest site, Ashley Bignall says, “I think a lot of young people get their information from the internet, but if you want to check something factual, it’s important to see it in a book.”

Another Star Books patron, seventeen-year-old Francis Haseldon said, “I think people are gradually dissociating more from books which is a shame. I think the act of reading makes you think — you confront ideas and opinions. I love the idea of the Occupy Library — a permanent place where people can interact with new ideas, or look at old ideas in a new way.”

So, are print books and the finite nature of the printed page a better source of information than the shifting sands of the internet? The “books vs. internet” argument is not new, nor has it seen a shortage of advocates for both sides.

While books have earned a trusted spot in our culture as legitimate sources of information, having been vetted by an entire network of people, the internet does not always have that same quality assurance — but it does have the wisdom of the crowds, relying that at least one reader will catch and point out the mistakes.

So tell us, do you trust books or the internet for information?

This entry was posted in Discussion and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.

2 Comments

  1. aisha
    Posted February 12, 2012 at 2:06 am | Permalink

    I prefer to read books and get information, because it is already edited by the book editors before they publish it. The information on the books are arranged and step by step. We can assure that the info we get are true.

  2. Jen
    Posted December 5, 2012 at 4:34 pm | Permalink

    I rely on the internet. I am pretty young and am too busy to pick up a book and browse for one specific thing. Where there is the internet and you just look up that one thing and hit search and… there it is. But I don’t depend on all websites like Wikiapeidia or Ask or anything that you can edit or post an answer that may not be true.

  • Get Publishing Perspectives in your inbox each day and stay up-to-date on international publishing.