« Digital, Resources

Friends, Romans, Librarians: Lend Me Your E-books (Part 2)

Yesterday, in Part 1, Erik Christopher looked at the e-book models offered to librarians by the United States’ two largest e-book retailers, Amazon.com and Barnes & Noble. Today, he considers the model offered by Overdrive and the future of lending as seen by the Open Book Alliance’s Peter Brantley.

Google eBookstore

By Erik Christopher

Despite the user-friendly devices and what they can offer from the e-book retailers, when it comes to the academic market, Amazon and B&N would do well to look at what the vendors and aggregators are doing if they wish to streamline their systems to work more closely in tandem with the systems already in place for libraries.

An example of one such company is OverDrive, which works with a variety of library systems, most notably in the public library arena, as well as with K-12 and higher education. “Our model is a one copy for one user at a time,” said David Burleigh, Director of Marketing at OverDrive. “We use Adobe Digital Editions for DRM and patrons can copy, print, paste, within limitations. On the admin side of it the librarians can set the lending period however they want — seven days, fourteen days, and so on.”

OverDrive offers this functionality for Sony Reader lending setup. This offers one advantage over Amazon and B&N in so far as the library can choose the amount of time a title is out. OverDrive also offers an app for iPhone and Android phones that also works with both PDF and ePub files.


Burleigh said that publishers can opt to go DRM free and the company is “dabbling in the multiple user/simultaneous use model” that other academic aggregators are using. “We have one publisher on board and others have expressed interest, but it’s new and we’ll take it slow.” With this type of model libraries can expect to see a cost increase per title, but a per user cost will be less. What that pricing structure will be, Burleigh didn’t say.

In regards to the current model in place he said: “OverDrive is trying to play Switzerland in this scenario. We’ve heard both positive and negative about the model, which is expected. We also have to work with both the publishers and authors and the rights they grant us, just because it’s digital doesn’t mean it’s out there for all without limits.” He believes that Google Books and the cloud-based model is challenging, but ultimately for the good. A project that OverDrive is working on is what they call OverDrive Certification Standard, a standard for device manufacturers to adhere to if they want to work with OverDrive and libraries.

The Answer May Be in the Cloud

Peter Brantley is Co-Founder at Open Book Alliance and Director, Bookserver Project at Internet Archive. He feels that OverDrive is getting it right though and trying to work with libraries the correct way., thought added that several things still need to change to facilitate easier and more efficient library e-book lending. “Downloading a file is too messy and Adobe DRM is too complex,” he said. “I see moving away from that and a better option would be to download from the web.”

Brantley believes that browser based lending and a moving to ePUB will make things easier. “Tech time and having to download e-books along with user frustration make it difficult. Open systems like the Android platform will help things move forward. B&N using the Nook wants to do more, but they have restraints imposed by the publishers, they are doing the best they can with those restraints. Hardware is a closed system and this will move to more software based.” He feels a network based authentication system is better.

Ultimately, Brantley says that publishers are going to need to talk with libraries, meet with them and form a partnership for e-book lending to really take off. In the academic world, publishers like Springer are doing some things that could work in the trade world. In the end, things will change and people need to keep an open mind as alternative systems come online and publishers move increasingly into “digital first” publications.

E-book lending for libraries is a complex issues. The models exist and libraries have options, yet none are quite ideal. A big part of this comes back to rights, especially in the trade market. Authors in particular may not be keen to see e-book lending take off. Author Marcus Sakey, has said, “As an author, I make my living when people buy my books. For that reason, it’s hard for me to come out gung-ho for lending. I don’t mind it as a way to sample my work, but ultimately I hope you choose to buy. Here’s the upside, though: e-books are cheap, and getting cheaper, which I love.  My preference would be to do away with digital lending, and instead continue to lower the price point of e-books.”

We have to remember that in the trade world the author wants and needs to be paid, as does the publisher. And the question remains: if e-books are increasingly more affordable, will libraries buy more copies? Most librarians want to be able to lend a book to multiple users at once and some librarians have already stated, they’ll pay more for more the privilege to do so.

None of this will be decided by retailers and aggregators simply taking an approach and saying, “This is our model, take it or leave it.” We need to be innovative and understand also that what is an e-book is also changing. If we move to a browser based model, in the cloud, where we have device agnostic environment, then things will truly get interesting. All we can ask for is patience; if you are a library, contact the trade publishers, if you are the publisher, start talking with libraries -– not to them but with them, get inside their head and use them to advise you. What’s the worst that could happen? That we figure this out?

DISCUSS: Is E-book Lending Bad News for Authors and Publishers?

This entry was posted in Digital, Resources and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.


  1. David Webb
    Posted January 7, 2011 at 11:49 am | Permalink

    As fond as I am of Mr Sakey’s writing, I have to point out that his claim “e-books are cheap, and getting cheaper” is not wholly accurate.

    In fact, when Amazon changed its pricing structure last year, many publishers moved the price of their ebooks from under $10 to $11.99 or more. Many books I’ve seen listed for sale online are cheaper in hardback than they are in ebook form.

    I don’t think ebooks are getting cheaper, though I do agree that they are becoming more mainstream.

    By the way, AT THE CITY’S EDGE from Mr Sakey, his wonderful second book called “fine piece of writing” by the great Lynn Kostoff, is $7.99 on the Kindle and $1.52 in hardback.

  2. Posted January 7, 2011 at 4:33 pm | Permalink

    First @David – I think his reference to ebooks “getting cheaper” he is in fact referring to the devices, not the digital file.

    I discovered Marcus Sakey before his first book was launched and from THE BLADE ITSELF to THE AMATEURS I have been a fan. I bought all five of his books to date and I will again in June with his next release. However, currently I only have 2 of the books in my possession as I have lent them out to friends and family, multiple times but never twice to the same person. By lending the books I’ve garnered Sakey at least 5 loyal readers and 3 others who have gone on to buy at least 1 more of his books.

    Lending is akin to word-of-mouth promotion, and any promotion is good promotion.

    Lending out books is not losing sales, it’s gaining readers. It’s a gateway for readers who wouldn’t have purchased book one with out the incentive.

    There will always be those who read for free either borrowing from friends or public libraries. You can’t lose a sale you never had.

  3. john faria
    Posted January 10, 2011 at 3:32 am | Permalink

    Dear institution

    My name is John Faria, I have a virtual editor,
    We just edited in pdf format epub and interactive.
    We will contact with the expectation that we can work together, because we edited but we need to distribute, so we contact you to ask if we can put our works for sale on your site and what costs would have to entail.
    I am waiting for a response with the following steps.

    Thank you for your attention,

    John Faria

  4. Bruce
    Posted January 14, 2011 at 3:12 pm | Permalink

    Overdrive lends ePub and PDF format ebooks using the Adobe Digital Editions, and is generally compatible with all current ebook readers except for the Kindle, not just the Sony readers. I use it with my B&N Nook.

  5. Kristi C.
    Posted January 15, 2011 at 8:41 am | Permalink

    One issue that I note in this article is the statement that the OverDrive Media Console app for Android and iPhone works with both EPUB and PDF formats. The OMC app allows downloads of EPUB formats only, not PDF. There are possibly other programs available for both mobile devices that may allow the reading of PDF-format books, but not through the OverDrive app. Due to the slowly increasing availability of EPUB titles, demand far outstrips supply with the one-book, one-patron model imposed on digital files, and it can prove near impossible for libraries to catch up and supply all the various formats that patrons are demanding. Resource sharing had aided print material availability between libraries; I would like to see publishers begin to expand digital rights, if DRM stays in place, to allow multiple licenses on titles.

  • Get Publishing Perspectives in your inbox each day and stay up-to-date on international publishing.